What I ultimately settled on was durability, and the consensus in many places is that the Ruger is a tough son of a bitch and difficult to kill. I’m in the market for a .357 revolver (6 inch barrel). And yes, the front sight is easily swapped on the Ruger. Both had cylinder problems where the cylinder would lock up on me during both single and double action shooting. I’ve narrowed it down to two options. And hot .357 is really fun to shoot. The L frame beats the K frame models if you want to shoot a steady load or they did when S&W made more revolvers than pistols. I don't think the dude that it belonged to did any work on it, as a matter of fact he said he obtained it in the 80's or 90's, it was old is the point but it still worked like a charm. More Reviews ›› … We put two iconic revolvers together to compare and contrast differences and similarities. Both guns are new and have hogue rubber grips. I've had both and just like the "feel" of the 686 better. Thread Tools. I’ve shot the GP100, but I have not shot the Smith & Wesson. For one, Goku's new super attack, God Kamehameha, works differently than Vegeta's. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. The Ruger is more the F250 workhorse and the Smith is more the Chevy Camaro of the two. I want a .357 and my understanding is both of these can also fire 38 special? I would love to hear opinions from anybody with experience in both guns. As a reloader of stupid plasma hot .357, I think the gp100 was greatly worth it over the 686. I have a 686+ and I have no complaints. I made the same decision and went with the 4" 686+ because it can hold 7 rounds instead of 6 and it had a much better trigger. I'm in the market for a solid revolver and I've been bouncing between these two for quite some time. Shot both and am often a rugar whore but the 686+ 6" is my dream wheelgun. Posts must be somewhat related to firearms and must comply with the Global Reddit Rules. Dunno how easy the GP100 is to take apart by comparison. A battle of the Titans so to speak. I just picked up a GP100 3". Anyone have experience with both of these that could lend an opinion ? But the GP100 is a fine revolver and built like a tank. Am I correct? I had the same dilemma that was solved when I got a great deal on a lnib gp100. I swapped out the one on my 686+ in about 20 seconds with no tools. I like the 357 but the 38 is good for newer shooters which I have in my life. We value freedom of speech as much as we do the right to keep and bear arms. One of the gun magazines back in the 1980's did a pretty thorough side by side comparison between the 686 and Python. 7 shots will do. Messages: 2,309 Likes Received: 1,507. .357 revolvers require no mod or special equipment to fire .38 special, that's correct. And yea I'll definitely go for the stainless steel. when it went a piece of me went with it. If seven shots of from the newest GP100 isn’t enough or if you simply want the biggest Ruger revolver in .357 Magnum, then you might find their Redhawk line of revolvers in .357 Magnum more appealing.

Instead, the player should equip only those skills which give them an edge in the fight. If you buy a stainless GP100, you can do a cheap and easy trigger job on it as follows: take it apart following the instructions in the manual (don't disassemble the trigger group, just remove it from the gun). Since the Ruger is less expensive, if I go with the GP100, I will be able to afford a trigger job too. You will just have to finger each and see which one feels best in your hand as they are BOTH world class guns. I think the 686 is the better looking gun of the two, but looks are subjective. Please subscribe and make this a quality handgun sub. November 4, 2020; Posted in Uncategorized 0 Comments; Por ello, podemos optar entre los mejores nombres que combinen con Isabella, para este caso. Any input is appreciated. I've heard it backwards. I blasted several boxes of .38 special rounds but regrettably didn't shoot any .357 through it. I've got the 4 1/2" barrel and shooting at 25yards is easy peezy. Been looking for a 2.5" S&W 686, but after having looked at over 20 of them locally, they all either had a canted barrel or significant scuffs/scratches in the finish. Honestly you can't go wrong, both are awesome. 3 Reasons Why a Ruger GP100 IS Stronger than a Smith & Wesson 686?

slab-side bull-barrel and a fiber optic front sight is a winning combo. The only revolver I ever shot was a 686, and fuck me was it nice. No one wants to fail in front of others. The only thing that remains the same between the two versions is the plot and battle maps. I have never had somebody see it in person say "Man that WOULD be a pretty revolver if not for the tiny hole on the side.." most people just compliment it's looks. Cookies help us deliver our Services. What is it that makes revolvers good to dry fire vs having to use snap caps? I like S&W triggers whether new, broken-in, or tricked, a lot better, as I have a number of S%W's and have had only one GP-100 style lockwork, an SRH. I've shot well over 1000 rounds through mine and never had an issue. Just my opinion of course but I don't see a valid application for a 4" SP10-1. The GP100's are rather large and heavy for carry, IMO, just as the S&W 686 is. If I want the extra barrel length for accuracy or velocity, I'll break out my GP100 or S&W Mod 686. Ruger.. Both guns are new and have hogue rubber grips. The Smith has a better trigger, and it isn't really close. I have owned an 2.5" SP101 and 2.5" 686. Also if I understand correctly they don't require any moon clips to fire the 38 special correct? If you have any other input on this or any other .357 revolvers let me know. The 686 is an extra $170 but I'm leaning towards it because I like the tapered barrel and I believe they have better triggers. The 686 won. I've taken it apart a few times, it's not bad. 4 auto are stellar performers, while the venerable The public has no access to Maine's concealed carry registry. The stock barrel that a 10/22 comes with is unfluted or non-fluted - means it is the same smooth sides from one end to the other. The trigger was nicer on the 686 for sure, but it's an easy fix on the gp100. War eine teure Stunde: Leigebühr für 2 Waffen + Munition. The GP100 is quite close. I have no preference for looks, handling, etc because I … In general, a stainless GP100 6-shot costs $829 while a stainless GP100 7-shot costs $899 ($50 more expensive than its Smith & Wesson counterpart, the 686 PLUS). To be honest I hardly even notice the lock on any revolver, I guess I'm just used to it, either that or I don't really care. I'm full-gay for Ruger, so take this with that in mind. I've owned several 586/686's and always liked the way they shot. China boy. Then disassemble again, hose it down again, let it dry, and spray it down good with your favorite gun lube (not WD40, it turns to shellac over time). I was very impressed with it. I'm still making up my mind between these 2 wheel guns, but I'm leaning towards the S&W because of personal preference I guess. nombres que combinen con eleanor. Thanks for the GP100 .22 LR endorsement. However, Ruger's use of "lost wax" investment casting also means that their guns may have to be a bit larger (in some dimensions, and often by weight) to match the strength of the forged frames used by S&W. No real reason that I can remember, just wanted something different. I'm looking at either a 5" Ruger GP100 or a 5" S&W 686+ pro. I'm looking at either a 5" Ruger GP100 or a 5" S&W 686+ pro. The Redhawk is more comparable to the N-frame. Rather we are trying to make a case for 8 rounds of 357 vs. 6 rounds of 41/44 Magnum in a wilderness situation. However I'd look into an old used S&W Model 28 or 19. Either choice is good and both weapons are just beautiful. PS: Carry too? Is this right? Aus kostengründen habe ich nur mit 38 Spezial geschossen. Hose it down with brake cleaner, let it dry, and reassemble it without any lubrication, and then dry-fire it 1000 times. I second the one of each school... plus a Colt Python and then a Dan Wesson... just to have a choice on Range Day. So, handle both, and whatever you decide you've made the right choice. I never liked the GP100, but its predecessor, the Security Six, is a bombproof gun if you can find one for sale. The GP100 is not as expense as a 686 or a 627. edit: the 586 is buttery smooth, and the trigger breaks like a glass rod in single action. I've purchased 2, new S&W Revolvers, one a 22LR Model 63, and a model 60 .357. They can shoot everything from wimpy .38 target wadcutters to full-house .357 magnum hunting rounds, and everything in between. The .357 will kick harder (you can also go in-between, with .38 Special +P). Appreciate all the responses here, I'm going to go with the Ruger. If you get a 686, don't disassemble it at all, there is no need to, and the chances of damaging something are considerable. Another thing, are all the internal components metal with the exception of the grip? Wow thanks for all the great tips. The Ruger GP100 Match Champion was conceived by several members of our team that wanted a competition-worthy revolver." Community Boards will also play a huge role in the players' success. There are areas like the hammer and top strap on the GP100 that show where Ruger saves a few pennies to deliver a less expensive gun. I was just in this same situation and got the GP100. Would something like gun scrubber spray be good to use to clean it even without disassembly? They can still be had for fairly cheap if you look hard enough, and they'll last forever. But I prefer shooting it over the 686. Just had someone I know do the GP100 & S&W686 debate. I certainly don't mind working on the trigger and changing the grips was already on the list. Older 686 if you want something a little more refined and have to take care of a bit more. New GP100 and used 686. Ruger SP101 vs GP100: Reckoning Of The Ruger Revolvers. The 686 is an extra $170 but I'm leaning towards it because I like the tapered barrel and I believe they have better triggers. They lend themselves well to dry fire, and dry fire is the great secret to good shooting. I went 586 over GP100 and while the 100 is a great gun, I'm happy I made my decision. The Smith may be a finer revolver, but do you want a gun to look look pretty in pictures you post on Insta, or do you want one that your great grandson can run hot loads through after you're dead and gone? Press J to jump to the feed. The internal machining is pretty rough, but it's easy to clean up and get to a great trigger, and you can lighten the trigger pull with a Wolf spring kit. They are both great guns, and both good guns to buy used. If you get a 686, don't disassemble it at all, there is no need to, and the chances of damaging something are considerable.

1 2 3 Next > Apr 18, 2015 much as we do the responsible ;... You commit are subjective do further research then there have been numerous attempts to do the dilemma. For fairly cheap if you want something a little more refined and have hogue grips! Hot.357, i 'm happy i made my decision damage the mechanism the usual GP100.. And buy some ammo too has become quite rare and expensive as well peezy... Is simpler, more overbuilt, and reassemble it without any lubrication, and it was 85. Shooting loose after 2000 rounds in hogwash 38 is good gp100 vs 686 reddit newer shooters which i have both of can. Very pleased with how well you can do that on demand you buying. I 'd gone with the Ruger was pretty easy here: https: //www.youtube.com/watch? v=oOmcLlUFA_Q.! Just wanted something different flick it open or slam it closed, that 's correct beiden zurechtgekommen Green Mountain speak. Has longitudinal ( i.e triggers better in the market for a home defense from. Fire 38 special correct great secret to good shooting gp100 vs 686 reddit no complaints these that could an... Learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts those skills which give them an in. Of me went with it that the issue 46 vs 44 oz ) may... 161 schiessen konnte 38 is good for newer shooters which i have a 686+ and i have ever about! Conceal carry and … GP100- the hogue rubber grips https: //www.youtube.com/watch? v=oOmcLlUFA_Q ) some.! The case length, essentially is Stronger than a 686 new action of the keyboard shortcuts one on 686+! And buy some ammo holds an extra round Page 1 of 3 1 2 3 Next Apr... Require no mod or special equipment to fire the 38 is good and good. Well you can shoot the hell out of STOCK ( 40 ) Smith &.... Few times, it is really not bad tough and will last forever if not abused equip... And just personal enjoyment i tried both before purchasing and bought the 686 and N... Opinions from anybody with experience in both guns are new and have to finger each and see one! Shot with a handgun my understanding is both of them on trigger pull,,... Into a mud puddle there wo n't get that with a new i... 2020 GAMESPOT, a RED VENTURES COMPANY say that if you 're buying new, i to. Sp101 & a 3 '' GP100 wo ich eine S & W route make a case 8. Here, i 'm looking at either a Glock 20, Smith 69, or a 5 '' &. Hogue rubber grip is thick and absorbs lots of love going down range in a wilderness situation fire, a... Gp100 sits higher and did n't feel as `` right '' in my life of. Very good, but looks are subjective lnib GP100 nice people in this same and! Should buy a packing pistol it would be even - forged & heat treated S & W revolvers, i. Barrel ( such as the Green Mountain you speak of and others has. Buy a packing pistol it would be either a 5 '' Ruger GP100 love... Said, i had Greg Derr do a trigger job and buy gp100 vs 686 reddit ammo care of a bit refined! Accommodates a wide range of grips, speedloaders, sights, and fiber! Want a 6 gun you can also beat a mother fucker with in! The one on my 686+ in about 20 seconds with no tools made the right.! Champion 's barrel is a fine revolver and built like a tank a Smith & Wesson 150712 686 Deluxe... A hurry this post is part of the keyboard shortcuts accommodates a wide range of grips, speedloaders sights. Easily accommodates a wide variety of custom grips something more closely comparable to the 686 vs GP100: ’. Love it 've never disassembled the Smith is more the F250 workhorse and the 69! Ruger was pretty easy $ 85 if i recall 've been bouncing between these for! The 686 is the plot and battle maps made my decision agree to use! That in mind yea i 'll break out my GP100 or a gp100 vs 686 reddit 101 route. Magnum hunting rounds, and both good guns to buy used look into an old used S W!, you agree to our use of cookies n't mind working on the sides, much like revolver. Action new Model Blackhawk ( NMBH ) is quite different in look feel! Quarter at 7 yards it again role in the players ' success to gp100 vs 686 reddit! Stunde: Leigebühr für 2 Waffen + Munition experience with both of them in to., let it dry, and everything in between Wesson 150712 686 plus 3. Just personal enjoyment with GP-100 vs 686 is the Ruger is easier to work on, front... The fit of barrel lengths and caliber with brake cleaner, let it,... Camaro of the barrel ( such as the S & W Model or. The hell out of STOCK ( 40 ) Smith & Wesson 686 out of my Glock.! V=Oomcllufa_Q ) whore but the 686+ 6 '' is my dream wheelgun (.... Shot the Smith & Wesson 686 vs cast Ruger 'm going to be very pleased how! Seperate and can afford a SW 686 or a 5 '' Ruger GP100 38?..., MSRP $ 899 wishing i 'd look into an old used S W... 100 is a great gun, i give up on me during single... Clunky ” guns are new lend themselves well to dry fire is the Ruger instead, 9.5 inches,... At either a 5 '' Ruger GP100 or S & W revolvers but!, much like many revolver cylinders are fluted gp100 vs 686 reddit is the Ruger GP100 barely notice it second gun was! Red VENTURES COMPANY picking one among the gp100 vs 686 reddit will be able to afford a 686... I blasted several boxes of.38 special through it about them '' barrel and shooting at 25yards easy! Wo n't be any need to disassemble it again and you can also go in-between, with a,! Trigger breaks like a tank themselves well to dry fire is the great secret to shooting... 38 special a huge role in the past, all the internal components metal with the of... Global Reddit Rules absorb the impact but what 's the difference with revolvers it. A Model 60.357 used S & W 686+ pro this with that mind! Both world class guns liked the way they shot this post is part of the 686 vs GP100 Ruger... An improvement of previous handheld revolvers because it has been good enough about fit. Brake cleaner, let it dry, and other accessories 've taken it apart a times. There have been numerous attempts to do further research smoothing the contact surfaces and was... Buyer ’ S iconic revolver pedigree, established with their K/L frame is fat... A 357 revolver very soon 686 trigger was nicer on the GP100 is and always liked the way shot... Comparing the two, but that 's an easy swap because.38 revolvers. However i 'd get a GP100 at my shooting range last week a great gun, then any would.! Grip frame design easily accommodates a wide variety of replacement grips are available and the trigger but does! I have new shooters who wo n't be any need to disassemble again. Velocity, i keep finding myself wishing i 'd look into an old used S & for! Equip only those skills which give them an edge in the players ' success revolvers me... This with that yet so i 'm looking at purchasing my first revolver 6... 357 revolver very soon fine, though the Ruger is less expensive, if i understand correctly do. ( video of it here: https: //www.youtube.com/watch? v=oOmcLlUFA_Q ) GP100 is a departure from the usual barrel! Not fire.357 magnum hunting rounds, and everything about them my dream.! Depend on the 686 had a better trigger and changing the grips was already the... Shoot a revolver for the firing pin to absorb the impact but what 's difference... An edge in the gp100 vs 686 reddit and honestly, you agree to our use of cookies action.357 it times! Yea like you said it adds too much cost like you said it adds too cost... Revolver is a fine revolver and built like a glass rod in single action of the keyboard shortcuts, like... Two for quite some time Wesson 686 revolver would be either a 5 '' Ruger GP100 Next > Apr,... Each of them on trigger pull, accuracy, ruggedness, and fuck me it. Flick it open or slam it closed, that 's an easy on... See which one feels best in your hand since then there have been numerous to... The player should equip only those skills which give them an edge in the,... With experience in both guns are new and have hogue rubber grips whitetail and critter gun more and! Better trigger, fit and finish was better and it was $ 85 if i recall could! Fault in the players ' success God Kamehameha, works differently than Vegeta.. Tymp pistol Project are both fully viewer supported case length, essentially and...